Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Trimester One, Blog One (due 8/31 by midnight)

You have two choices for this week’s blog response:

#1: Respond to the following prompt using one of the four methods described in your blog handout: Continue our class discussion of good readers by explaining how your view of a good reader has evolved over the week. Reflect upon the notes you took and the points we discussed in class to provide a detailed response here.
OR
#2: Visit the link below to view a cartoon from The New Yorker. Then, respond to the following questions: 1) How do the details of the cartoon contribute to the humor it evokes? (That’s right—fondle the details.) 2) What comment does this cartoon seem to be making about our society or about an aspect of society? 3) Why might an editor have chosen to include this particular cartoon in the August issue of The New Yorker?

http://www.newyorker.com/humor/issuecartoons/2007/08/27/cartoons_20070820?slide=5#showHeader

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

#1.
When I first read the articles discussing how to read properly in any context, I was slightly apprehensive. I was under the impression that I would have everything I have ever learned overturned and I would have to relearn entirely how to read. But, in fact, I found out that I now agree with nearly everything Perrine and Nabokov felt about analyzing any piece of literature. Nabokov is very opinionated about the fact that we cannot take so much “creative license”, if you will, that we lose the authors original ideas and concepts behind the story or poem. I agree and understand where he is coming from when he say’s that we must “fondle” the details. See, when I was little and my mother would read stories to my sister and I , she would have us close our eyes while she read and imagine what was happening as if it were happening around us. That reading technique has kind of stuck with me and I now find myself reading with an overactive imagination, or so I thought. Now I realize I was merely being a good and thorough reader.

IJB said...

The first time I read the Nabokov article I had my wall up because of comments I had heard about it. One thing I originally disagreed with Nabokov on was his opinion that a good reader did not put themselves in the main character's shoes. I did not like reading this because that is something I commonly do. Now that I think about it, it makes sense; if I focus solely on one person in the book then I cannot get the whole picture. I plan on paying attention more to how I read books in the future and see if I can read like Vladmir wants me to.

Anonymous said...

At the sight of the Nabokov article, I really believed that it would be a guide to just learning how to read and comprehend my literature more often. However, it somewhat startled me when he started to go into his opinionated hypothesis with a more deeper tone. He really emphasized his views on the difference of novel writers and non-fiction writers. I do believe that his statements on how to critical read are leading the right direction. For instance, when he stated that we must not get to trapped in and relate with only one character, it would be a more clear picture with knowing the book as a whole then to just one character. All in all Nabokov's article does require a vast community of open mindedness to actually interpret and take in his criticism on the literary aspects of reading.

Jordan Weyenberg said...

#2
1) The man being ticketed is driving a nice two-door car, which gives the impression that he is successful, or at least that he is well-off. He is also dressed well, so one can assume that he is well-educated and professional. His apparent situation then just makes it even more humorous that he would make such an idiotic statement.
2) The author seems to be criticizing the parenting of today. The fact that an apparently well-educated mam would make that statement just shows that in today's society kids can get away with virtually anything and not have to learn respect or boundaries.
3) The editior may have made this cartoon in August because it is generally when school starts again and parents generally see their kids more. It is a bash on our society, but it is also a wake-up-call to today's parents that there are still rules that their children must follow in the real world.

Brett said...

#1.

My view on how to become a good reader has changed, hopefully for the better, after reading the two articles this week. At first I strongly disagreed with Nabokov's thought that you can not identify with the main character, because ever since elementary school, that is what I was taught to do. However, after having the discussion in class, I could see that it does drastically reduce the "artistic delight" that the author is trying to paint and that it is best to envision the story as a fly on the wall.
As far as Perrine's point of view, I generally agreed with him in that when reading poetry you must have a keen eye for details and you must make minimal assumptions. I have the trouble of reading poetry and taking it very literally. Perrines' examples of poetry interpretations have opened my eyes as a reader on how to identify the hidden meanings of poetry.

Anonymous said...

#1) My opinion, funnily enough, of a good reader of literature was actually affirmed by reading Nabokov's article. What really struck me was his concept of a reader being a re-reader. I get a lot of flack for reading books over and over again, and this article gave me a sturdy defense against it! Though, I will admit that the whole concept of "not relating to the character" threw me a little bit, but like Isaac mentioned, it made sense after I gave it some thought. Nabokov's article gave me a lot more insight on how to be a better reader, and I find myself already practicing some of his concepts.
Perrine, on the other hand, completely obliterated me. I'm kind of new to reading (and subsequently understanding) poetry, so I feel that his article will come in to particular use.

Anonymous said...

(This is a continuation on Perrine.)
When I first got interested in poetry this summer, I was reading on a level that only appreciated the surface levels, like the flowery composition and word choice. I never tried to guess the author's true feelings, and I figured that I could interpret the poem any way I desired. Perrine graciously pointed out to me that I was going about this poetry business in the entirely wrong way. Some people remarked that he was bossy about it, but I appreciated his frankness. He was only trying to convey that by creating your own meaning for a poem, it defeats the author's entire purpose. He's not saying poetry isn't up for interpretation; he merely states that there are boundaries for these interpretations. You can interpret all you want, but it has to meet certain requirements. I had never thought of poetry in this way. It changed my whole outlook, but in a very good way.

P.S. This word verification thing is annoying.

Unknown said...

#2
1) In the cartoon we see that a particularly well off man (due to both his appearance as well as the appearance of his car) being pulled over on what appears to be a freeway. In the background we see the streetlights as well as the sign similar to that on the by-pass. This makes it even "funnier" and even more "hilarious" because the man appears to be in good status.
2) This comic is trying to show how funny it is that today's parenting methods and/or the lack thereof are beginning to show their true colors. This is an attempt at showing us how poorly parents are developing their children.
3) Most likely the author posted this comic in August because it is the beginning of the school year. Automatically connecting parents with their children in one way or another, this helps to connect the overly lenient parents with their boundless children.

George said...

The man being issued the ticket in the cartoon is trying to blame his mistake on his parents. The driver says that his parents never set boundaries thus using his parents as a scapegoat. Taking responsibility for your own actions is one of the biggest problems with society today. Everyone who has a problem will try to blame someone else for their mistake. The cartoon does a nice job of showing who most teeneage kids blame their mistakes on saying that they were never taught better or that their parents do it so why can't they.

Taylor said...

#2:
1)Because the man in the car is fairly young, the cartoon implys that the man is of a younger generation, just recently released into the adult world. He also appears to be a successful man, shown by his groomed appearance and modern car. These details add to the humor of the defiant nature of today's teens.
2)The cartoon portrays the lack of responsibilitiy and decency of younger generations, as well as their assumptions of always sliding by with little or no repremendations. The logic behind this is aimed at the sufficiency of authority in these young lives; which should be managed in part by both parents and teachers. But with the incline in flexibility of rules in each generation, the world is evolving at a negative slope compared to the standards of society.
3)Including this cartoon in the August edition is logical because August generally marks the end of summer, and the start of supposed structure. However, not all parents are aware of how much structure the schools are providing their children with presently, and that they should be more involved in teaching their children morals and common decency.

Unknown said...

When first reading Nabokov I was simply astounded by his eloquence and ideas. I found myself nodding along with him as his beautiful writing and thought sunk in. I completely agreed from day one with the ideas he so beautifully laid out. For me the most compelling of arguments is that one must almost wipe the slate of their existence clean in order to truly understand and appreciate an artist’s work. Nabokov stated “we should always remember that the work of art is invariably the creation of a new world, so that the first thing we should do is to study that new world as closely as possible, approaching it as something brand new, having no obvious connection with the worlds we already know.” This statement, while positively vast in its difficulties, is an absolute truth. One must first shed themselves, opening themselves to the work as if they’ve never experienced before. By letting our intentions, ideas, and experience guide the way we judge a world and its protagonists completely alters the truth behind it. It is similar to mixing the purest of water with mud. You can not tamper with the art by allowing yourself to have any connection or empathy to the piece. Nabokov’s brilliance in his statements was not only impactful, but beautifully stated as well. I aspire to one day be capable of the difficult separation he has stated here.

kinz said...

1)Upon my first glance at the cartoon, I immediately concluded that the man being ticketed is an adult. As previously discussed, the classier make of his vehicle along with the professional appearence of his glasses suggest a defined maturity. The man's confident posture and firm grip on the steering wheel, especially in the obviously awkward and humbling situation, create an illusion of dominance. Keith's proposal that the location is on a major highway indicates he's commuting to/from work. All details considered, the fact than a successful man of a certain age still feels permitted to blame his parents for his immature mistakes bring a bout of ridiculous sarcasm to the piece.
2)The cartoon focuses on the elongating slope America's youth travel to adulthood. By showing an obvious adult partaking in childlike behavior, the cartoonist showcases the issue that younger generations are generally struggling with accepting the responsibility forced upon them with unescapable aging.
3)August marks the beginning of the new school year, which triggers added responsibilities and behavioral learning. Changing from the carelessness of summer to a studious environment, students might more easily learn to accept their oncoming maturity.

$~young broc~$ said...

The first thing i noticed about th e cartoon was the size of the officers head. It appears to be very small, symbolizing that policeman lack intelligence. The second thing i noticed was that the man in the car looked like a man that has never done anything wrong in his life. This might suggest that cops are wasting their time trying to fix the small issues that they are too busy to worry about the major problems in this world. The quote at the bottom shows that the man in the car is not responsible. Since he is probably a young driver (judging from the fact that he is using his parents as a scapegoat), it could be concluded that young drivers are not mature enough to be behind the wheel and that most are bad drivers. About society in general, it shows how no one in America is willing to accept the consequences when they do something wrong. Most people make excuses to get out of their punishment. In the cartoon, the driver is trying to make excuses so he does not recieve a ticket. A possibility of why the author posted the cartoon in August is to show the negative impacts of lower gas prices, if there are any at all. He might be trying to show how lower prices make teens think they can drive faster and not worry about getting good gas mileage to save money. Since the prices have dropped the last month, young drivers might find in illogical to worry about the money issue, drive faster than the speed limit, and recieve a ticket after being pulled over by a cop. Overall, this cartoon shows the negative side of drivers and how irresponsible young Americans can be.

lindsey said...

1)In the cartoon a man who appears to be in his late twenties is ticketed by a police officer. The most humorous part of this issue is perhaps the speculation that the man is older and seems "well-to-do" yet he is accusing his parents of unfavorable parenting skills.
2)The article apparently is assuming that society today is too busy to teach their offspring how to behave and act with common sense and decency. I presume that the author might have been subtly stating that through the generations kids have become more unruly and disobedient.
3) This author might have been sending an admonition to teenagers as they head back to school to be alert.I believe this author is trying to use comical relief to further his point by furtively telling kids to respect their boundaries, and freedom given to them.

Miss Stump said...

Here are a few comments for the good of the cause—the cause being your grades as well as your sense of humor. Please note that you may need to use your newly acquired critical reading skills to discern which of these comments should be taken seriously and which should be abandoned after a good laugh.

1.Let us all remember to turn on the spell check/grammar check in our heads. Know does not equal no. Remember, you can write your blog in Word and then paste it into the blog comment box. And now that I’ve ridiculed all of you for said errors, let us hope that my blog is error-free!

2.Asking rhetorical questions—as many of you did—is always a good idea, assuming, of course, that they are written in regards to the topic at hand. Referring to one another’s writing is great! Certainly, continue this type of dialogue that many of you created by actually answering others’ questions.

3.Making connections to current events is a great idea—even if your examples are always political ones.

4.Contrary to potentially popular belief, you will not receive extra credit for posting more than once, especially if your second blog is an exact replica of the first!

5.Keep a calendar handy to remember which day of the week it is.

6.Always use details to support your assertions. If you say that annotating has helped you become a good reader, then give an example.

Unknown said...

The details in this cartoon of a police man and a man in a car help people relate to it. I think that it symbolizes that adult-figures aren't as involved in their childs life as they could be. I think that the cartoonists used this setting for the month of August because it is back to school time.