Wednesday, September 10, 2008

Trimester One, Blog Three (due 9/14 by midnight)

#1: Respond to the following prompt using one of the four methods described in your blog handout: Continue our class discussion about the identity of the speaker in The Canterbury Tales assumes. Think about the tone as he comments on particular individuals. Do you pick up on any biases? Does this make him reliable/unreliable?

OR

#2: Choose a character from The Canterbury Tales, and compare him or her to a modern figure. Make your comparisons specific, detailed—and appropriate. Feel free to agree or disagree with your classmates’ comparisons.

14 comments:

lindsey said...

Two prominent figures that I wish to compare are the Knight and Chuck Norris. Both are very goal-oriented, and have excellent fighting technics. Apparently the Knight fought in fifteen deathly battles, yet the outcome was always one of victory. As everyone knows the odds are for Chuck Norris in a fight as well. When the narrator of The Canterbury Tales describes the Knight he states that "he loved chivalry", meaning that the Knight held reverence to courtesy, generosity, and all things that pertained to knighthood. Chuck Norris's standards appear similar also, for two of the goals that Chuck bases his live upon are,"I will look for the good in all people and make them feel worthwhile.If I have nothing good to say about a person, I will say nothing." Furthermore,I believe that both individuals are devoted to God. Chuck vows to,"...always remain loyal to God," and the Knight endures battle for his faith. Contrary to these diligent warriors' uniform morals,their apparel is quite diverse. Chuck Norris is known for his popular western attire while the Knight wears his battle equipment. To conclude this analogy, I think that though Chuck Norris and the Knight have different appearances that their brave hearts are the same. The lesson is you can not judge a book by its cover.

Anonymous said...

The ideal figure that i would review about and discuss over is the Squire. He is a son to the knight, and he helps him with his certain duties, while maintaining quite a social life with the women. I would almost say that the person in modern day times compared to the squire is George Clooney. The acting of George Clooney depicts that of the Squire by far. Clooney is no doubt the ladie's man. He is always the main actor in his movies, but he plays more of a subtle role, and not expressing forward a role such as the Knight.

Brett said...

#2

The two people that I would choose to compare would be the merchant and Ed McMahon. Both of the comparable characters appear to be living the life of luxury, but they are actually secretly hiding their insurmountable debt. The merchant dresses very eloquently and rides an exquisite horse leading people to believe he is wealthy, but hides the fact that he is deeply in debt.
McMahon was the longtime voice of the Tonight Show and the face of Star Search, not to mention countless movie roles. One would think that with these well paying jobs his multi-million dollar house would be paid for, but the truth is that he is actually over $600.000 behind in payments. This debt is just on his house, he also owes about $1.000.000 total on unpaid loans and a couple other legalities.

So to sum up, both the merchant and McMahon show off their flashy clothing or their estate to look important in the public's eye, but the truth is that they are nothing more than debtors.

Credit to Wikipedia for the McMahon statistics.

Unknown said...

#2

While reading The Canterbury Tales, one character, The Manciple, was recognized as a prominent example of one of America's funniest and heavily blamed national leaders, George W. Bush. Upon the reading of "Now isn't it a marvel of God's grace That an illiterate man can outpace The wisdom of a heap of learned men?" I immediately thought of our nation's leader and his poor skills of maintaining America. Despite being such a poor example of educated men, both the manciple and George W. Bush succeed in their occupations by what Chaucer calls "his masters- he had more than thirty then-". This not only could be compared to the way the democracy's leaders are supported with a vast array of droning
bureaucrats, but show how even though the leader lacks proper skill, he can be pulled along through the use of others' work.

**no longer part of post**

Here's a perfect example :)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YGgswKlXEZk

$~young broc~$ said...

When I read about the Cook in The Canterbury Tales, the first person I thought of was Chef Ramsey from Hell’s Kitchen. Both of these figures are very skilled in their careers of cooking. Each knows what ingredients are needed to make the perfect dish. Also, I pictured the Cook to be somewhat of a bossy man, clearly coexistent with Chef Ramsey. Most professional chefs need to be arrogant to run their business properly anyway. Finally, I could see Chef Ramsey having a giant ulcer on his knee without anyone knowing. I just hope he doesn’t put any “ingredients” from his sore into his cooking.

Jordan Weyenberg said...

First, in response to Austin's post:

I can see how you would think that George Clooney and the Squire are alike, but when I read the character I got an impression of someone more like Brad Pitt (would that make Clooney the night since they almost always star that way?). I just see him as a younger man with many talents, though not necessarily a master of any of them, and has an easy time with the ladies(and gets in trouble because of it too).

Now in response to Keith's post:

I can see the comparison that you make; although I generally support President Bush it is true that he can have some serious trouble speaking (but seriously, can't we just listen to what he says not how he says it? Everyone else messes up too they just don't talk on prime-time). However, the Manciple conjured up a different political figure to me: Barack Obama. Obama is (relatively) untested in the political arena, has very little experience to tout on his resume (community organizer??), and he is quite young. I compare the term "illiterate" with un-learned considering the time period of The Canterbury Tales, and Obama is fairly obviously "un-learned" in some respects. Yet, Barack Obama is a figure that millions revere and respect, even when compared to the likes of previous opponents Joe Biden and Hillary Clinton, who are both far more tested than Obama. Apparently, to Americans, Obama's smooth talking is worth much more than "The wisdom of a heap of learned men."

Anonymous said...

#2
I think that today, Elizabeth Taylor would fit the character of the Wife of Bath perfectly. Elizabeth Taylor has been married a lot, I think about 8 times, and the Wife has been married 5 times. So you can probably imagine that they'd have much in common in that category alone. The Wife of Bath has a lot of life experience; she's traveled to the Middle East three times in her life, which was no small feat in those days. Elizabeth Taylor had a lot of life experience too. She was a very talented actress and a major Hollywood star. The two also seem to be very adaptable and flexile with their surroundings; the Wife adapts to her different husbands, and Elizabeth adapted to different husbands and different movie roles. Both Elizabeth and the Wife seem like very colorful characters that live illustrious lives. They choose to live life to the fullest.

In response to the George Clooney/Brad Pitt debate, I think that Clooney would be the knight, because he seems very chivalrous and concerned in the world's issues. I don't think Brad Pitt necessarily fits the squire description, but I don't think he could fit the knight's description either. Brad Pitt's too much of a man's man to be the emotional squire...

Taylor said...

The overall tone of the speaker is primarily informational and descriptive. The prologue is written so that each character can be summarized before they receive their own chapter. The speaker could be read as somewhat biased as he is merely describing the character as he views them, without any input from the characters themselves. He has spent enough time to characterize their personality, yet he still generates his own opinions per character, leaving the reader with only the speaker's opinionated reviews. However, the speaker is not entirely unreliable, as he does provide factual information that provides a more tangible insight to the reader. Unfortunately, the speakers spends fluctuated amounts of time on each character, some with more, less with others. This leaves the reader without a consistent pattern of knowledge for each character.

Unknown said...

The character that I compared to a modern day person would have to be the cook and Emmeril. I picked these two characters because they both seem to me, to be loud and obnoxious people. They also are strict and want things done the right way. One final comparison between the two are that, they are both chefs that like food and they're both italian.

Anonymous said...

When I read the Prologue to The Canterbury Tales I felt that the overall tone of the narrator was very omniscient. He seemed to know a lot about every character and although he made fun of some of the characters and was very respectful of others, I think he is a very reliable narrator because he seems to know too much about almost ever character to be biased. The omniscient tone helps shed light on not only the good things about each characters life and personality but also the bad things such as the merchants lack of funds or the woman of baths prostitute-like behavior. The quote that Lindsey used, "I will look for the good in all people and make them feel worthwhile.If I have nothing good to say about a person, I will say nothing.", proves this idea.

IJB said...

I would like to compare the yeoman to a modern, but fictional character. This person is Dale Gribble from "King of the Hill." Much like the yeoman, Dale likes his weapons. In one episode we see how many he really has. He produces from his person two pistols on shoulder holsters and one at his ankle, a knife at the other ankle and one at his thigh; this is just to go to work as an exterminator. If we include all the guns in his home and even a bomb under his neighbor's mailbox then Dale's weapons greatly exceed those of the yeoman. Granted he is paranoid and does not trust the U.S. government. That is still quite a few weapons for one man though. The yeoman in turn has his fair share of weapons for his time. These include a bow, finely crafted arrows, a sword, a dirk (dagger), a shield, and a hunting horn. The two characters contrast in that the yeoman uses his weapons for noble purposes, that of a forester, and Dale is just scared and paranoid.

George said...

I think that the knight is comparable to modern day Skyler Titus. The knight described in the book has been through many great battles, and has always come out the victor. It also mentions that the book that the knight is not one to boast. His wardrobe is very simple unlike many knights in that time. Most knights were very flashy, and were also very boastful of their accomplishments in battle. The knight, in my opinion, is like Skyler Titus. He has been involved in many competitions and is the best at what he does, beating many opponents. Skyler is not like most "jocks" that people think of in high school. He never brags about his accomplishments to anyone that does not ask about them. Skyler, like the knight in the novel, dresses very plain for his status that he has. He does not dress to impress everyone, but rather dresses as anyone else does.

George said...

I think that the knight is comparable to modern day Skyler Titus. The knight described in the book has been through many great battles, and has always come out the victor. It also mentions that the book that the knight is not one to boast. His wardrobe is very simple unlike many knights in that time. Most knights were very flashy, and were also very boastful of their accomplishments in battle. The knight, in my opinion, is like Skyler Titus. He has been involved in many competitions and is the best at what he does, beating many opponents. Skyler is not like most "jocks" that people think of in high school. He never brags about his accomplishments to anyone that does not ask about them. Skyler, like the knight in the novel, dresses very plain for his status that he has. He does not dress to impress everyone, but rather dresses as anyone else does.

Unknown said...

I agree with Savannah’s statement that the narrator’s tone appears to be omniscient, but it is also very entertaining. When first venturing into the prologue I was surprised with how much Chaucer used rhyming, but after delving in I realized that his eloquence actually flows very well. Chaucer’s narrator reminded me of an opera in a way, constantly changing tones from the noble march of the knight, to the whimsical slightly unnerving friar and so on. His narrator appears to be a very intelligent character, one who is also gifted with winning the trust, or perhaps even, spying on others. The narrator appears to be, at least to me, watching the happenings of those around him with awe. His feelings and statements about each are varied in length and opinion. Also, it is hard to truly deem whether he is boasting of a person’s honor and values or demonstrating a subtle sarcasm at the ideas of each. Which character in the Canterbury Tales is truly the narrator’s favorite is difficult to say, but it is easily stated that he does take interest in each.
A small side note and question… Does this narrator remind anyone else of Lemony Snickett? I recall watching a short video of him at a book fair at Woodview and he talked about following people around and taking notes on their attitude, conversations, and habits for his stories. I wonder if the aforementioned author took this habit from Chaucer?