Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Trimester One, Blog Six (due 10/12 by midnight)

Think about the critical reading skills you’ve practiced this year throughout the poetry unit and throughout The Awakening unit. Many of you indicated—via the last blog’s goals—that you wish to further develop these skills by annotating, fondling the details, etc. How have those skills helped you read through the research materials you’ve found? Do you find yourself reading the research materials differently? Have you researched for this essay differently than you have for other essays after hearing the research tips that Mrs. Bontrager presented? Reflect upon your growth as a reader and as a researcher.

Finally, let the rest of the class know what topic you're researching! Feel free to comment on others' topics.

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

Mrs. Bontrager's presentation was a wake up call to my reasearching skills. I realized there were many other sites that would carry the information I needed for my paper this time. A big site that stood out was the CQ Reasearcher. It had loads and loads of articles that one could find to help someone with a research topic. I find myself annotating more than usual on printed out documents on the web. I highlight the words and key information, while putting them into my own words.

lindsey said...

Throughout this year I have definitely learned to explore details and how to view literature with a different perspective. While researching I have applied the key principles of skimming, noting specific ideas, and throughly understanding what concepts are trying to portray. The research tips that Mrs. Bontrager presented helped me to realize that sources should originate from a variety of locations so a paper does not seem one-sided. As a reader and researcher I believe that I am not quite so naive in absorbing information. The topic I chose to elaborate on is the link of mental illnesses to society, and how the government can implement plans to help them.

$~young broc~$ said...

I feel that Mrs. Bontrager’s presentation taught me some things I had never thought of before. I had never heard of the CQ Researcher before. Also, I now look closer at web sites to make sure there information is professionally presented. This helps me find more valid support for my paper. As far as annotating, I have been printing off my sources and highlighting information for later reference. I think my attention to detail is growing and my critical reading skills are getting better. I feel like I am actually researching rather than skimming web sites for supporting statements. Overall, I think I have improved. Oh, and good jokes poodle!

Jordan Weyenberg said...

1. I would just like to point out that poodle's statements and jokes made my day.
2. I'm researching the causes of the financial situation that warranted the government's rescue package.
3. I feel like I have more thoroughly researched this topic than ever before. Perhaps this is because I am so interested in it and I want to learn more about it regardless of the fact that I'm doing it for a class. However, I think the revelation of CQ Researcher and knowing for what type of articles to look have also helped me greatly. And, thanks to Miss Stump, I figured out how to make comments on Office documents, which makes pasting articles and annotating them a breeze, so I can actually read what I write now!

Unknown said...

To be quite honest I don't think that critical reading skills will directly match up with research reading skills. This is simply because of the difference between fiction and non-fiction. When reading fiction, one interprets what they believe the writer meant to say, whereas in non-fiction facts and statements are often direct and clearly explained. My research for this essay has thus far remained the same as my research for other essays I have completed in the class, mainly because I believe my current skills should suffice. Mrs. Bontrager merely pointed out that college level material was, in essence, more difficult, requiring more work under less time and basically engraved further into our heads the stressful and rigorous strains that college will induce. Rather than fret about how terrible it will be in the future, or preparing by "practicing" for college ... I choose to simply enjoy my current state as a senior for the short time I'll spend as one. Therefore I believe i will grow enough through my reading and researching in this class to make me survive in the harsh college enviornmnet. My research topic is, as usual, one based upon ethics ... the use and research of stem cells.


*** I'm unsure who poodle is but ... wow ... ***

Unknown said...

I think that Mrs. Bontrager's presentation helped me find a topic mostly because of the CQ Researcher tool. I feel that I am researching the same way I always have because it works for me. I'm researching steroids in sports.

Anonymous said...

While I think Mrs. Bontrager's presentation was informative, I don't think it really said anything different from what I've heard before. Don't use Wikipedia. Make sure your websites are reliable sources and aren't fake or misinformed. Use up-to-date information. However, I do feel that the CQ Researcher website has helped me tremendously. It helped me refine my argument of my paper when I came across an interesting article relating to my general topic.

Since we've learned new critical reading skills, I do think that I read information differently. I don't just absorb the information. I actually take the time to sift through it and think about what the author's trying to convey. I used to just take it in and not think anything about it, but now I analyze it and dissect it.

Anonymous said...

P.S.--- I forgot to mention what topic I'm researching. I'm researching the media bias of Islamic religion.

Anonymous said...

309So far I have learned some very valuable techniques to assist in proper interpretation of literature. And not just fictitous literature but factual as well. While researching for my project I have been able to locate very reliable and helpful resources through the information given to us by Mrs. Bontrager. I like having resources that I do not have to look for as well such as INSPIRE and the CQ Researcher. Due to these many helpful tips I have tons of sources for my topic. My topic is the possible causes of autism.

Brett said...

I find myself using databases after listening to Mrs. Bontrager's presentation. I was unaware that CQ Researcher was on our website, which is pretty sad seeing as how I update it everyday. CQ Researcher has a few documents on my topic which helped to finish the evidence portion of my proposal.

Prior to that, I would usually just search Google and select the first relevant site that was listed. If that would not work, then I would use the reliable website, Wikipedia, to find enough information to get my paper started. I find the databases more reliable than the random searching, because a database usually offers credible sources.
I have not changed how I search through my sources, because I find it much faster to use Ctrl+F to find key words when viewing a longer document.

My topic is the effects of music piracy.


**Links and text effects added just to annoy Whammy**

Taylor said...

I'm hoping that the critical reading skills will be of help to me when I annotate the copies I print off from my website sources. Also, rereading will be of big help to me on much of the research. Mrs. Bontrager introduced us to the CQ Researcher, which I had no idea existed. This is a big relief from mindlessly googling through all my research without much luck. Overall, I hope to find more information for this paper because of the knowledge I have gained this year alone.

IJB said...

First in response to Poodle, whoever you are, I do not agree with any of your jokes. I don't know where you got them, but not one even made me chuckle.

Now on to the topic of researching:
When Mrs. Bontrager gave her presentation about CQ Researcher I thought that it would probably not give me any help I could not get somewhere else. A couple days later I found out differently. CQ Researcher gave me some good starts on my topic of global warming and the polar ice caps. I don't find myself researching like I read poems and The Awakening though. I can't annotate since the articles are on a computer, and I'm not doing CRJs for them either. I tend to read a paragraph, put it in my own words and then record it onto a notes sheet to be later revised.

Unknown said...

First off, a small note to our very educated friend “poodle”, congratulations! I hope your very intelligent comment has left you with a feeling of elated joy, that you do indeed, sound like an idiot :)
On a more serious note, I have found certain aspects of our literature analysis to be very helpful when researching for this project, specifically, Nabokov’s statement about credibility with your sources. While I was not present for the lecture given by out new and very gracious librarian I have heard from other sources that she too, focuses on credibility. With this in mind, I have attempted to research more current sources on my topic, which has been somewhat difficult due to its age. I have found though that the inspire database has been great because you can specify what years you want your articles to span from.
My topic thus far, is the impact of the corporate world on the Amazon rainforest.

Unknown said...

ps. suspicions about whom our poodle is. George. Keith. Mr. Uebler.

anyone else?

Unknown said...

pss emphasis on Uebler

Brett said...

I knows who Poodle is :)

Miss Stump said...

Well, Poodle, your entrance into our blog has certainly caused a stir. I had hoped that you would identify yourself so that we could all bow in reverance at your ability to copy and paste derogatory jokes from a seemingly questionable internet site into our more intellectually-minded class blog. Bravo! Hint: I am being sarcastic here. In the future, I remind you to remember that there's a time and place to share offensive comments (this blog not being one of them).