Tuesday, January 20, 2009
Trimester Two, Blog Six (due 1/25 by midnight)
Reread page 487 in Everything’s an Argument (you should have already read it when you read Chapter 16). Provide your own example of a situation and its context in which evidence other than hard, factual evidence is just as, if not more, advantageous. The example you provide can be one based on a real experience (such as the one noted in the book), or you can formulate your own hypothetical experience. Address, as necessary, the rationale for the evidence you believe to be the most persuasive.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

13 comments:
While standardized tests may prove to be an adequate way of determining one's intellegence, it is not always effective. Hard facts and statistics do not always provide a good way of measuring how smart a child may be. Anecdotes of students who perform well in school academically and otherwise, but do not perform equally on standardized tests such as the SATS could be an effective way to present this argument. Metaphors and interviews could also prove to be effective.
If one were writing an examination of the school's budget crisis, hard evidence would be incredibly difficult to come by. Interviews or anecdotes from teachers or administrators. These would be just as effective due to the issue being more local.
When someone is on trial for murder or any other crime, there is sometimes no hard evidence to be found. In these cases, the lawyers must rely solely on eyewitness accounts. Even though eyewitness accounts are not the most accurate, they would be the most beneficial for that situation if there were several different people who could give the same account.
In the instance of the current recession, real impact is not usually measured as well by stock quotes and GDP numbers. It is much more effective to find a person or family struggling to make ends meet because of the economy and relay their story. Newscasts do this, and I'm sure people are more affected by the sad individual stories then the DOW falling 50 points. This can basically be summed up by saying statistics and measurements do a poor job of measuring the gravity of a situation when it involves peoples' lives.
Everyday events tend to use evidence other than hard evidence. For example, a student stating they saw another individual cheating or a child telling their mother their sibling pushed them. Although these are not earth shattering events, like some of these other examples, hard evidence cannot be used in these situations. A teacher must rely on the story they are being told and the trustworthiness of the student. The mother must rely on her knowledge of their child's personality in order to determine what occured.
In divorce or child custody cases, hard evidence and statistics cannot provide a base for a ruling. Judges and juries rely on witnesses to provide personal accounts of events to decide cases. Hard facts and statistics alone do not decide such cases; such cases are ones involving emotions, feelings, and real people going through hard times. These situations cannot be described with numbers and science.
Religion is probably the pinnacle of this topic. There's no hard evidence or statistic that proves God's existence. People simply choose to believe in Him. I don't want people to take this in the wrong way, I wholeheartedly believe in God, I'm just saying that there isn't any scientific proof that He exists. While we believe what was written in the Bible and take that and the words of the prophets as evidence enough to believe, it cannot be proven that it is actually true.
To relate this to a personal experience that happened to me, it would have to be my driving test. I failed it the first time because the lady said that I didn't come to a complete stop, whatever that means. So, I had to wait two weeks and take it again at Plymouth. By this time I had a Zibbyhawk for ND football season and she was afraid of me. This is why I passed my drivers exam. In conclusion one should annotate and look for metaphors in the drivers manual, or take the easy way out and strive fear into the person grading your driving. God Bless!
When one is tasked with judging any sort of art, be it paintings, plays, or music, quantitative analysis takes a back seat to qualitative judgments, and even in this case, qualitative judgments are subjective to the eye of the beholder. Whether judging Louie Armstrong's soulful jazz to Maynard Ferguson's screaming trumpet, Gean Kelly's athletic dancing to Fred Astaire's smooth ballroom dancing, or Shawn Connery's James Bond, to Roger Moore, Pierce Brosnan, or Daniel Craig, every critic will judge on their own qualitative basis, not quantitative. When it comes to art, excellence indeed is perceived in the eye of the beholder. The only judgment that can be quantified comes from those that "vote with their feet."
Although I'm not sure i fully understand what this blog is asking, I think one example in which an argument could be won without the use of hard factual evidence would have to be advertising. Regardless of how much faster a pair of Nikes can make you run, displaying a commercial with an olympic athlete running a race and winning because he was wearing a pair obviously makes them to be good shoes. Despite the fact that no hard factual evidence was presented, the consumer immediately realizes that these shoes are "the shiznit" and will soon flock to get a pair of their own.
If one were to argue that their AP English teacher was a mass-murdering psychopath, hard evidence may be hard to come by due to his/her meticulous planning and/or divine intervention by Harrison Ford. In this case, shady and scary personality traits may provide a solid basis for proving that they are, in fact, a cold-blooded murderer.
I definately have to argree with Kerry. Religion and philosophy is one topic that using hard, factual evidence is next to impossible with. For topics such as these, one must rely on the pathos as well as the ethos to appeal to the audience, which may be most effective through anecedotes and statements from people who have experienced your topic.
correction* are both topics....
Post a Comment