Thursday, March 12, 2009

Trimester Three, Blog Two (due 3/15 at midnight)

After considering our class discussion regarding the Lynne Truss excerpt and rudeness, come to your own conclusion about rudeness. Make a statement about rudeness (such as Truss’ statement that “abuse is becoming accepted as the quickest and smartest way of dealing with criticism in all areas of life”), and support your assertion with anecdotal examples (130). You should also comment on at least one other classmate’s post. If you are the first to post, pose a thoughtful question for your classmates to consider.

10 comments:

Time for some Chazzle Dazzle said...

What defines rudeness?
Rudeness often occurs when soemone feels uncomfortbale in a situation or realizes they have been proven wrong. The lack of ability to accept truth often is why rudeness occurs becasue no one likes to hear that they are wrong, incorrect, or something has not gone the way they like.

lindsey said...

To define the concept of rudeness one must consider a moral code that each individual lives by. Something that might prove offensive to one category of people might be taken as a compliment by another. An example of this would a simple phrase as "Oh my! You have lost weight!" Now a majority of the time most Americans would be flattered by this comment, but in some countries maintaining a larger body type is desirable. I agree with Chaz though, that it seems Americans have become intolerable to criticism.They believe any answer should be redeemable as clever because its their God-given right to state anything off the top of their heads.

$~young broc~$ said...

Rudeness is simply acting in a way to put someone else out of their comfort zone. Making a student read aloud in class when they do not want to or telling someone they have a giant zit in public is just rude; the person feels awkward and wants to run and hide. It is simply rude to put a person in this position. I agree with Chaz when he says being proven wrong is an awkward position. The person acts rudely because they do not know how to act any other way.

Anonymous said...

Rudeness is definitely becoming more commonplace. It seems like people become more and more upset when people disturb their normalcy instead of just accepting changes--I think this is a big source of rude behavior. For example, if a flight is delayed because of bad weather around the airport, passengers often behave very rudely towards the flight attendants and people at the counter (people who, ironically enough, have nothing to do with the weather). Their routines and plans have been altered, and they react poorly.
Lindsey made a good point about the weight loss. The definitions of what is physically attractive vary so much from country to country that one could unintentionally offend when a compliment was intended.

Trent Stutzman said...

I believe that rudeness is growing in our society. There are more people nowadays that for some reason think that they are above everyone else and don't need any help. Like Chaz said, people generally do not like to hear that they are wrong. As a result, when someone tries to help them or point something out, they shove it back in the innocent helper's face. Another common source of rudeness is when someone has a crappy day. When someone might disagree with this person or tell them something that they already know, it is hard to keep their negative feelings inside. It is extremely easy to offend someone in this situation without even thinking about it.

George said...

Rudeness comes in many different ways. It can be something that someone says to another or even an action that someones does. An example of being rude is asking someone if they lost at an important sporting event even when the person who asked knows that the person competing lost. Another way someone can be rude is simply by cutting someone in line at the cinema. Nothing needs to be said about this action to know that it is rude. I agree with Chaz in that ones comfort zone has a lot to do with taking something as rude or not.

Chuck Norris has brass cahonas said...

Well unfortunately i did Truss' excerpt home with me, but I will try to include examples I can recall. I think that rudeness is extremely subjective from person to person. Different people interpret the actions of others differently. Rudeness to me happens when people fail to speak their minds and give "little white lies" in an attempt to make a person feel better. I would much rather have the truth be told, however harsh, because it would allow me to better myself. Truss gives an anecdote on this as she describes a friend a patronizes her. Truss fails to call him out on it, so the problem never reaches a solution. I believe that Katherine is correct in stating that rudeness has become more commonplace, and that rudeness can result from grouchiness or frustration.

Jordan Weyenberg said...

Rudeness seems to have simply become a staple in today's society the world over. As Truss's excerpt exemplifies, it manifests differently in each culture, but by and large it is now a commonly accepted form of communication. Although this may have its advantages, on the whole this is an extremely disturbing phenomenon that threatens civility in every facet of society. Although on the surface we are so concerned with being politically correct, this generally applies only to those in the spotlight or when referring to a group as a whole. On the level of personal communication, rudeness is now the preferred medium of oral exchange. As one can see from any sitcom, it is perceived as both funny and effective, but reality is far different. While it may provide a surface laugh or chuckle, it is never healthy to communicate in such a way for either party in a conversation. Perhaps this is why teenagers, and Western society as a whole, view the people around them as "fake" or just "putting on a show." This goes along with Wes's statement about people covering up what they really mean with "little white lies." Rarely in today's world do we see anyone say what they really mean in a still-civil manner. Either a person is obscenely rude in their statements, or so concerned with not being rude that the true meaning of their words is buried. Perhaps that is why people find it so difficult to speak their mind at all and instead fall into the trap of being "fake."

Anonymous said...

Rudeness seems to occur in many places as different examples. My biggest rudeness experience i can think of is when the common courtesies of people aren't met. For instance when Truss talks about how the person brought their dog on board a subway. For those who don't know, subways are very tight and compacted. Yea it is not that big of a deal, but why bring your dog on the subway, when people need to ride the subway too. I feel Trent is right onto what i am saying. People have this egotistical mindset, thinking everything must be about them. If it has progressively gotten worse, just wonder at how bad it will be in another ten years.... Especially if Barack Obama is still presitdent. YIKES...

Unknown said...

Rudeness is simply one's selfish interests or ideas interfering and/or disturbing those around them. These ideas are often best kept to one's self, however many people have no regard for the good of those who surround them and therefore show no reserve in the content of their actions around them. An example of this would be someone proclaiming how terrible of a teacher they thought a certain math teacher was in order to invoke a laugh from their fellow classmates. This is only a selfish act to draw attention to oneself. I must say that most of the other posts give up too easily when they say that we must simply accept this. I believe that if people can start to live together as opposed to for themselves, then this issue of rudeness could die away.

-Don't know if this will post me as JESS or not but its keith ;)