Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Trimester One, Blog Two (due 9/7 by midnight)

As a change from last week’s blog, please respond this week using option #2, #3, or #4 on your blog guidelines. This allows you some room for creativity in your answer, especially option #4, which directs you to draw your inspiration from class discussion (perhaps you want to further elaborate on the worms in "To His Coy Mistress"). Reread the blog options!

Here’s a thought to add (moment of brilliance for Stump): Consider finding your own cartoon—political or otherwise—and include the link to it. Then, pose your own questions for the class.

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

Okay... Honestly everybody, I do have to announce that when i read Home Burial for the first time, I interpreted it as the man actually had just killed their son. The woman was pacing back and forth looking out the "frames" which I thought was maybe a window. He came in and when he walked up to her, I noticed how she cowered and told herself she had to get out of there when he looked at what she saw. Now, in addition to these happenings, he started to become very declaratory towards the woman, but the part that really had me believing he was not in a safe state, was when he told the woman "If you do, where do you mean to go, I'll follow you and bring you back by force... I will!!!" That is when it hit me that this could be interpreted both ways. Not only a grief situation, but an angered one where there really could be some forced death in this poem. If anyone has any ideas on this, I would love to hear them. See you guys in AP ENGLISH WOO HOOO!

Anonymous said...

In the poem "Home Burial" by Robert Frost, one stanza really stood out for me. Lines 95-111 pose an interesting concept. It discusses how the woman feels about the friends of the ill. She claims that when someone is pronounced fatally ill, their friends can try to go with someone to death. I feel this is explaining that a persons friends can try to empathize with the ill and be there for them but they cannot actually follow them into death. She also says "No, from the time when one is sick to death, One is alone, and he dies more alone." This statement reminds me of the movie Donnie Darko. Those who have seen the movie will recognize that these words are similar to the words Grandma Death whispers to Donnie. In order to entirely understand the connection between the movie and the poem one must watch Donnie Darko. This I suggest seeing as how this is one of my favorite movies.
I also agree with what both Grandma Death and Amy, the wife in the poem, have to say. It is true. Most people do not have the courage to stay with someone through their time of need. In order to lessen their loss they begin to move on even before the ill-fated person has passed away. I feel that we must push past our own hurt and help the person who is sick, because I know that I do not want to die alone.

lindsey said...

"My Last Duchess" can be depicted as a disturbing poem. As this duke starts reminiscing over his young bride one starts to feel an uneasiness within the poem. In line 22 it is clear that the husband is overtaken with envy and later is infuriated in lines 32-33 when he states,"...I know not how-as if she ranked my gift of a nine-hundred-years-old name." Throughout the poem I believe that it is safe to say that the duke's jealousy got the best of him. Insisting that stooping to reason with her was below his nobility, the duke formed a chaotic situation. He wanted absolute power, and in my opinion, I think that he wished to contain this ravishing beauty to himself. When I began reading lines 45-47 I became concerned; I interpreted the phrase,"Then all smiles stopped together," as the period when the duke eliminated her from his life. I believe the duke was in pursuit for happiness, and that even a naive, oblivious duchess was incapable of satisfying his need to be glorified.

$~young broc~$ said...

have to agree with what Austen said. When I read the poem, I interpreted it as if he killed the son and was burying it in the back yard. I imagined the scene as if Amy knew the son had died, but she did not know why. Then I assumed she looked out the window and saw her husband laying him to rest. Since the husband was considerably intense with what he said to Amy, I pictured her realizing that he killed their son. Then she decided she needed to get away from him, for there was no telling if he had plans to kill her as well. I think the lines that lead me to this conclusion were lines 118-120: “If—you—do!” She was opening the door wider. / “Where do you mean to go? First tell me that. / I’ll follow you and bring you back by force. I will!—“. Also, the way the way Amy acted on the stairs made me believe she was really afraid and wanted nothing more to do with him. After reading this, I had decided which character’s side I wanted to be on. I felt bad for Amy and basically thought that the husband was a psycho. But after our discussion in class, I recognized that the story could be interpreted in other ways. I like my way better though. It makes it more of a thrill!

IJB said...

In response to Austin I can see the poem as the husband having just killed his baby son. However, I choose to read the poem as one where there is a grieving wife and a seemingly emotionless husband. Amy, his wife, accuses the nameless husband of not caring at all about the buried son, "If you had any feelings, you that dug With your own hand-- how could you?-- his little grave;" I think that, unlike his wife, this father has already grieved, and in a different way. I believe that while digging his son's grave he was indeed feeling sorrow. When he reentered his house he said, "Three foggy mornings and one rainy day Will rot the best birch fence a man can build." Granted this was an insensitive thing to say to his wife, I think that he was just at a loss of what to say because he had left his grief at the grave. (Any thoughts on this?) Even though I think he did mourn their dead son, that's as far as I can go. I have no arguments that he was a good husband or even nice to his wife. "There you have said it all and you feel better. You won't go now. You're crying. Close the door...There's someone coming down the road!" Just when I think his compassionate side is showing itself he is more worried about his appearance to a neighbor than his wife. I am not surprised that she often leaves the house to find consolation.

Brett said...

I had the same general thoughts as Isaac had, in that the man was emotionless rather than an abusive husband and father. He does make a few domineering comments toward the Amy, but for the most part I feel that he is frustrated with his wife for not recognizing that he is not as emotional as she is. Men tend to take their grief out physically while women usually grieve by letting out their emotion. He had to find a to physically let out his emotion, and going along with what Isaac said I feel that digging the son's grave was his way of grieving. He wanted to leave his emotions at the grave site instead of constantly dwelling on them like Amy does. This provided him with a positive outlet of grief instead of turning it into something negative which could endanger himself or Amy.

Brett said...

EDIT: He had to find a way to physically let out his emotion, and going along with what Isaac said I feel that digging the son's grave was his way of grieving.

Is there no way to edit these?

Taylor said...

After the discussions of "My Last Duchess" I was left with the impression that the poet was a materialistic man. He was so proud of his painting, just the mere image of his Duchess, yet lacked the same love for her departed spirit. He also made a point to show off a bronzed statue nonchalantly, after just reminiscing his late wife. He was a very proud man as well, being sure to inform the guest on all he presented to the Duchess. He was very shallow in the way he talked, always highlighting his good deeds. And this is the very nature that causes me to believe he killed the Duchess himself. Is he truly looking for a partner or just a meek trophy wife to submit to his authority?

Anonymous said...

At first I didn't agree with you when you gave your opinion in class, Austen, but now that I've read yours and others' posts I can definitely see from that perspective. That view just never occurred to me before but I guess I didn't analyze it as thoroughly as you did. But I think I found something about Frost that might disprove that theory...
What particularly struck me about "Home Burial" is that I really, really wanted to know the backstory for this poem, or at least what inspired it. The emotions like grief and frustration illustrated in the poem seemed too real to be a complete fabrication. Sure enough, after "googling" Robert Frost, I found out that he lived a very sad life. Frost's father died of TB when Frost himself was young, his sister was submitted into a mental hospital, he, his mother, and his wife suffered from depression, one son died from cholera, another committed suicide, one daughter died after giving birth, and he had to submit another daughter into a mental institution. What I really think inspired this poem was that his daughter Elinor died a few days after they were born. Out of all those children, only 2 of them survived their father. I thought that background clarified some of the questions that I had after reading it, and it definitely helped me understand the poem better. It was illuminating, albeit rather depressing.

Anonymous said...

--Edit
...died a few days after *she was* born (not "they were")

Unknown said...

http://www.xkcd.com/263/

This is one of my favorite online comic series, and one of the less straight-forward examples i could find.

1. What is this comic ultimately trying to prove?

2. How does this comic tie into an AP english class?

3. Why is math considered a "perfect universal truth"?


**I'm unsure if i'm supposed to answer any of these**

Jordan Weyenberg said...

In response to Kerry's post:

That helps me quite a bit as well. I knew that Frost had a tough life and that many of his poems came from his personal issues, but I didn't know that he had so many problems involving his children. I can see much more clearly now why "Home Burial" is so intricate; Frost himself had almost certainly gone through something similar.

This is in response to Austen's post:

I can certainly see why you would interpret it that way. My initial impression in the first 50 stanzas was the same, but once I read further and reread it I changed my opinion to the one we discussed in class. While the husband does display some violent tendencies, in general he seems to simply be on a different page than his wife is emotionally, and his outbursts seem to simply be due to him being frustrated.

Jordan Weyenberg said...

EDIT: After reading Brett's edit, I'd just like to point out that I agree with that completely. I that saying that the husband is completely devoid of emotion is a bit unfair; he simply displays them differently.

Unknown said...

this is very long :(
When reading Frost’s “Home Burial” I was completely in awe. The two people in this poem are so ripped apart by their grief that they are completely incapacitated and can no longer see or understand each other’s true heartache. The woman has become a bitter shell, simply looking for someone to blame, for an outlet would you, for her pain. Her “unfeeling” husband becomes her aim. She is so consumed with her resentment that she can not even stand to be near him, literally cowering beneath him when he approaches. To her, he has become the evil monster that took away her beloved child. I feel that the poem suggests that this torment has commenced for some considerable amount of time, perhaps a few weeks.
It also appears that the male of this story has also become an instigator in a way. While his wife has planted the seed of bitterness and blame in his heart he feeds these entities with his anger. While at first he attempts to soothe her wounds he quickly turns defensive against her accusations stating, “I do think, though, you overdo it a little. What was it brought you up to think it the thing, to take your mother-loss of a first child so inconsolably – in the face of love? You’d think his memory might be satisfied…” I believe that he is playing the role of a “strong” husband in his own mind. He digs the grave methodically, as if dazed, “making the gravel leap and leap in air, leap up, like that, like that, and land so lightly and roll back down the mound beside the hole.” His lack of emotion in this single action demonstrates that he is not empty of pain, but perhaps consumed by his emptiness. He attempts to appear “alright” speaking of the fences instead of his own tragic state. Sadly though, his wife can not reach inside his soul to see the true despair brewing there. After he has mourned quietly and believes he can now approach his grieving wife, he then ventures to the stairs and finally sees what has tormented her. He can not understand though, that his method of grieving has given her an object to blame. He reaches out to her, only to have her turn the other way. Growing defensive, he now channels his pain with the situation into anger. I do not believe though that the statement, “Where do you mean to go? First tell me that. I’ll follow and bring you back by force. I will…” was meant as a threat of violence, but one of love. He is telling her, no matter where you go, I will not let this be, I will not let us be torn apart, I will bring you back and we will make things right.
I feel an immense amount of sadness with this poem, because in truth, it is a mirror of Frost’s interpretation of how grief can so easily destroy love. These two individuals were both victims to a fate neither could have controlled. To know that Frost must have had some understanding of this concept is a shame. But perhaps, he was trying to warn people to first attempt to understand before you blame.

George said...

Keith I am going to help out and answer your questions. After looking at the comic I think that it is, in the end, trying to prove that almost everything is not certain. This can relate to AP English because of the poetry we have been covering. Trying to find meanings for the poetry that we read is hard and there is no certain answers. In the comic the one figure says that no one can impart perfect universal truths except math teachers. This is completely true because math is one of the only subjects that for every question there is one solid answer.